Brewer, David J.

$75.00

1893 slip signed as Associate Justice, one of the Court’s ultra-conservatives!

Description

Type: Signed slip
Description: (1837-1910) Conservative Associate Justice 1889-1910. Born in Turkey, he was a nephew of Stephen J. Field, a future Court colleague. Attended Wesleyan University and Yale, graduating Phi Beta Kappa 1856. He was a Yale classmate of Henry B. Brown, another future Court colleague. After graduation, Brewer read law in the office of his uncle, David Dudley Field, then enrolled at Albany Law School, graduating in 1858. Brewer went to Colorado in search of gold, returning 1859 to Leavenworth, Kansas. He was named Commissioner of the Federal Circuit Court in Leavenworth in 1861. He became a municipal and state jurist, elected to the state Supreme Court 1870, serving 14 years.

In 1884, Brewer was nominated by President Arthur to the US Circuit Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit, then nominated by President Harrison to the US Supreme Court in 1889 to the seat vacated by Stanley Matthews. He served on the Court for 20 years until his 1910 death. A conservative, he was a major contributor to the doctrine of substantive due process, arguing that certain activities are entirely outside government control. He frequently sided with Court majorities that struck down property rights restrictions. Brewer took temporary leave (1895-98) from the Court to be President of the US Commission on the Boundary Between Venezuela and British Guiana, created by Congress to arbitrate the Venezuela Crisis of 1895.

He authored the unanimous opinion of the Court in Muller v. Oregon (1908) supporting a law restricting working hours for women. He also authored In re Debs, (1895), upholding federal injunctions to suppress labor strikes. He joined the majority to strike down the federal income tax in Pollock v. Farmers Loan & Trust Co. (1895). He favored a narrow interpretation of the Sherman Antitrust Act in US v. E. C. Knight Co.  (1895), but cast the deciding vote in Northern Securities Co. v. US (1904) to block a corporate merger on antitrust grounds. Brewer generally ruled against African-Americans in civil rights cases, but consistently voted in favor of Chinese immigrants. He opposed imperialism and, in the Insular Cases  rejected the idea that the Constitution did not apply in full to territories. His majority opinion in Church of the Holy Trinity v. US (1892) contained a frequently criticized claim that the United States “is a Christian nation”.

While public sentiment regarding Justice Brewer was mixed after his death, he was almost never discussed favorably after the 1930s, being generally described as an ultra-conservative who adhered closely to laissez-faire principles and made the courts subservient to corporations. Although late-t20th century revisionist scholars took a less negative view of the Fuller Court as a whole, Brewer’s reputation did not rise:

3 ¼ x 5 ½ slip signed as Associate Justice, Washington, June 26, 1893.

Condition: Very good

Product Search

Product categories

Quick Links